Housing review group should be retained to strengthen Dundee’s emergency response, says Councillor
Dundee Liberal Democrat Councillor Craig Duncan has called for a constructive rethink of the decision to dissolve the council’s Housing Best Value Review Group following concerns raised by Shelter Scotland.
Councillor Duncan says the group should be retained so that it can continue its detailed examination of housing services, alongside public oversight of the housing emergency by the Neighbourhood, Housing and Communities Committee.
His amendment proposing this approach, seconded by Bailie Fraser Macpherson at the committee meeting on 26th October, was voted down by SNP and Labour councillors.
Councillor Duncan said:
“Everyone wants to see more people able to access a safe, suitable and affordable home. The progress reported in reducing homelessness applications and unsuitable accommodation is welcome, and reflects important work by council staff and partner organisations.”
“But the scale of Dundee’s housing emergency means we must make the best possible use of the experience and expertise available to us.”
“The Housing Best Value Review Group brought together councillors, tenant representatives and other stakeholders, providing an opportunity to examine housing services in detail and offer constructive challenge.”
“Our proposal was straightforward: bring oversight of the housing emergency into the public committee, while retaining the review group to continue its other valuable work. These are complementary roles, and both can help improve outcomes for tenants and people waiting for a home.”
Shelter Scotland has raised concerns about how progress will be measured and how organisations beyond the council can contribute in the future.
Councillor Duncan said:
“This deserves a considered response. We need clear goals, regular public reporting and meaningful opportunities for tenants and housing partners to help shape improvements.”
“I hope colleagues will be willing to look again at retaining the group, with a clear remit that supports the committee’s work.”
“This is about working together to give Dundee the strongest possible response to the housing emergency. With continuing pressures on repairs, housing finances and service delivery, there is real value in keeping a forum dedicated to detailed scrutiny and improvement.”