Dundee Liberal Democrats have today (Sunday 6th August) welcomed the double-blow to Labour's determination to press ahead with plans to introduce identity cards with two reports accusing the government of confusion and of keeping the public in the dark.
Firstly, a House of Commons committee reported that plans for ID cards were "inconsistent" and "lacking clarity" and questioned the Home Office's claim that the overall cost would be half the £19bn estimate of analysts. And, secondly, Richard Thomas, the information commissioner, found that the Treasury analysis of the scheme was being unfairly kept secret and ordered details to be made public.
"Identity cards will cost a fortune and won't stop terrorism or fraud. If Tony Blair wants to nail his legacy to ID cards then it will be a suitable end to his faltering premiership."
Locally, Dundee Liberal Democrat Council Group Leader, Cllr Fraser Macpherson, said, "Labour's ID cards proposals are wholly flawed and highly expensive - it is a failing government that ignores all the warning signs and criticism of a flawed policy. Labour is also ignoring public opinion on this issue."
Bookmark this story at:
del.icio.us
Digg
Facebook
LibDig
reddit
StumbleUpon
Print this news story.
Previous news story: Dundee LibDem Convener supports "Who pays Max Tax" competition (Thu 3rd Aug 2006).
Next news story: Dundee Liberal Democrats welcome this year's Dundee Partnership awards (Mon 7th Aug 2006).
Related News Stories:
Fri 26th Sep 2008:
Dundee Liberal Democrats say ID cards a 'laminated poll tax'.
Sun 15th Jun 2008:
Dundee Liberal Democrats back improved BBC coverage of Scotland.
Sat 31st May 2008:
Dundee Liberal Democrats back National Recycling Week.
Wed 28th May 2008:
Dundee Liberal Democrats slam Post Office closures.
Sun 4th May 2008:
Dundee LibDems praise party's performance as Labour has poll disaster.
Fri 18th Apr 2008:
Dundee LibDems reiterate criticism over Labour's abolition of 10p tax rate.
Sat 12th Apr 2008:
Dundee Liberal Democrats back inquiry into BAE scandal.
Thu 20th Mar 2008:
Dundee Liberal Democrats call for action for Scottish schools improvements.
Sat 15th Mar 2008:
Dundee Liberal Democrats say report shows ID cards scheme should be scrapped.
Fri 14th Mar 2008:
Dundee Liberal Democrats slam "green cop out" Budget.
Sun 9th Mar 2008:
Dundee Liberal Democrats back campaign to reduce excess packaging.
Wed 5th Mar 2008:
Dundee Liberal Democrats - supporting Fairtrade.
Mon 3rd Mar 2008:
Dundee Liberal Democrats welcome party's debt advice proposals.
Dundee Liberal Democrats condemn DWP staffing cuts.
Sat 1st Mar 2008:
Dundee Liberal Democrats applaud Stephen's "positive vision for Scotland".
Tue 26th Feb 2008:
Dundee Liberal Democrats say denial of referendum on Europe an outrage .
Wed 13th Feb 2008:
Dundee Liberal Democrats welcome '2008: Women & the Vote'.
Fri 8th Feb 2008:
Dundee Liberal Democrats back Clegg's call over economy.
Wed 6th Feb 2008:
Dundee LibDems slam Labour's failures on Tax Credits.
Sat 2nd Feb 2008:
Dundee Liberal Democrats welcome 10-point plan to tackle flooding across the UK.
Fri 21st Dec 2007:
Happy Christmas from Dundee Liberal Democrats!
Sun 9th Sep 2007:
Dundee Liberal Democrats announce Lochee candidate.
Fri 13th Jul 2007:
Dundee Liberal Democrats express further concern about Tax Credits shambles.
Mon 18th Jun 2007:
Dundee Liberal Democrats welcome Scottish Parliament's rejection of Trident replacement.
Wed 9th May 2007:
Dundee City Council Administration discussions "constructive and positive" say Dundee Liberal Democrats.
Fri 4th May 2007:
Dundee Liberal Democrats say "thank you!".
Tue 1st May 2007:
Dundee Liberal Democrats support positive approach towards young people.
Tue 10th Apr 2007:
Leading Liberal Democrats back trunk road improvements for Dundee.
Tue 13th Mar 2007:
North East Scotland breakthrough on the cards, say Dundee Liberal Democrats.
Mon 12th Mar 2007:
Dundee LibDems welcome news that young voters flocking to the Liberal Democrats.
Fri 1st Jun 2007:
Dundee Liberal Democrats welcome action to cut carrier bag use.
Mon 26th Feb 2007:
Dundee Liberal Democrats supporting Fairtrade Fortnight in the City.
Tue 13th Feb 2007:
Dundee Liberal Democrats back measures to tackle crime.
Sun 11th Feb 2007:
Dundee Liberal Democrats slam Child Support Agency bonuses.
Sat 3rd Feb 2007:
Dundee Liberal Democrats support effective green taxes.
Wed 24th Jan 2007:
A Greener, more Liberal Britain, backed by Dundee Liberal Democrats .
Mon 22nd Jan 2007:
Dundee Liberal Democrats say "We can cut crime".
Sat 20th Jan 2007:
Dundee Liberal Democrats welcome climate change declaration.
Tue 16th Jan 2007:
SNP figures just don't add up, say Dundee Liberal Democrats.
Mon 15th Jan 2007:
Dundee Liberal Democrats support new powers for the Scottish Parliament.
Sun 14th Jan 2007:
Dundee Liberal Democrats in action! Campaigning across Dundee.
Tue 9th Jan 2007:
Dundee Liberal Democrats welcome travel scheme for young Scots.
Sat 30th Dec 2006:
Dundee Liberal Democrats support new carers' package for Scotland.
Sat 23rd Dec 2006:
Happy Christmas from Dundee Liberal Democrats!
Tue 19th Dec 2006:
SNP economics a mess, say Dundee Liberal Democrats.
Sun 10th Dec 2006:
"Tories a fake on green issues," say Dundee Liberal Democrats.
Sat 9th Dec 2006:
Dundee Liberal Democrats support calls for Green Budget.
Sat 25th Nov 2006:
Dundee LibDems slam "billions wasted on Iraq disaster".
Wed 22nd Nov 2006:
Dundee LibDems slam Labour's failure on Pension Credits.
Mon 20th Nov 2006:
Dundee Liberal Democrats back saving Post Office Network.
Sat 18th Nov 2006:
Dundee Liberal Democrats welcome proposal to help more Scots establish businesses.
Mon 13th Nov 2006:
Dundee Liberal Democrats back more powers to Scottish Parliament.
Fri 3rd Nov 2006:
Dundee Liberal Democrats say ageist Housing Benefit policy must be reformed.
Sun 29th Oct 2006:
Dundee Liberal Democrats say Energy Saving Week has been "really positive".
Thu 26th Oct 2006:
Dundee Liberal Democrats back "End Child Poverty Month".
Wed 25th Oct 2006:
Dundee Liberal Democrats support Friends' Week 2006 .
Sun 22nd Oct 2006:
Dundee Liberal Democrats say "young people's wage discrimination must stop".
Sat 14th Oct 2006:
Dundee Liberal Democrats say party is in great shape for 2007 campaign.
"SNP simply not up to the job," say Dundee Liberal Democrats.
Fri 13th Oct 2006:
Backing for Sir Menzies Campbell over Iraq from Dundee Liberal Democrats.
Wed 11th Oct 2006:
Young workers deserve equal pay, say Dundee Liberal Democrats.
Tue 10th Oct 2006:
Dundee Liberal Democrats say ID cards "a terrible waste of valuable public funds".
Thu 5th Oct 2006:
Dundee LibDems criticise failure of Labour's Tax Credits.
Mon 2nd Oct 2006:
Dundee Liberal Democrats welcome Dundee's retail success.
Sun 1st Oct 2006:
Dundee Liberal Democrats express concern over fuel price rises.
Fri 29th Sep 2006:
Effect of Council Tax disastrous, say Dundee Liberal Democrats.
Sat 23rd Sep 2006:
Dundee LibDems agree - Liberal Democrats are the party for the many - not the few.
Fri 22nd Sep 2006:
Dundee Liberal Democrats welcome Sir Menzies Campbell's Speech.
Thu 21st Sep 2006:
Dundee Liberal Democrats welcome film - the environment needs action!
Tue 19th Sep 2006:
"SNP claims about LibDems show they are worried," say Dundee Liberal Democrats.
Thu 14th Sep 2006:
Dundee Liberal Democrats welcome Schools Digital Network Report.
Thu 7th Sep 2006:
Dundee Liberal Democrats say security breaches "prove flaws in ID cards proposal".
Sun 3rd Sep 2006:
Dundee Liberal Democrats support pensions reform.
Tue 22nd Aug 2006:
Former Dundee SNP councillor joins Dundee Liberal Democrats.
Fri 11th Aug 2006:
LibDem tax package would be good for people of Dundee, say Dundee Liberal Democrats.
Thu 10th Aug 2006:
Dundee Liberal Democrats welcome Labour climbdown on volunteers' lunch costs.
Mon 7th Aug 2006:
Dundee Liberal Democrats welcome this year's Dundee Partnership awards.
Thu 27th Jul 2006:
Dundee Liberal Democrats hit out at energy price hikes.
Passport price preposterous, say Dundee Liberal Democrats.
Sun 23rd Jul 2006:
Dundee Liberal Democrats' concern over poor take-up of Pension Credit.
Fri 21st Jul 2006:
Labour's pensions policy a failure, say Dundee Liberal Democrats.
Wed 19th Jul 2006:
Dundee Liberal Democrats condemn cash machine charges.
Tue 18th Jul 2006:
Dundee Liberal Democrats praise new City Council Handyperson Service.
Mon 17th Jul 2006:
Dundee Liberal Democrats support home composting initiative.
Fri 14th Jul 2006:
Dundee LibDems support ''Say NO to Labour's extradition rough justice''.
Wed 5th Jul 2006:
Dundee Liberal Democrats welcome "A New Strategy for Iraq".
Sun 2nd Jul 2006:
Liberal Democrats' great prospects ahead in Dundee!
Thu 29th Jun 2006:
Dundee Liberal Democrats give support Dundee Summer Festival 2006.
Sat 24th Jun 2006:
Liberal Democrats - working for Dundee!
Tue 30th May 2006:
Dundee Liberal Democrats support Green Week 2006.
Sat 13th May 2006:
Dundee Liberal Democrats encourage members to support "Liberal Democrat News".
Thu 11th May 2006:
Pensions reform urgently needed, say Dundee Liberal Democrats.
"Nuclear not the future," say Dundee Liberal Democrats.
Tue 2nd May 2006:
Dundee Liberal Democrats welcome report on promoting green lifestyles.
Sun 23rd Apr 2006:
Cameron's "concern" for environment" just empty rhetoric, say Dundee Liberal Democrats.
Sun 16th Apr 2006:
Dundee Liberal Democrats campaign in Moray.
Fri 7th Apr 2006:
Dundee LibDem Secretary says Liberal Democrats are Dundee's growing party.
Wed 5th Apr 2006:
Dundee LibDems highlight Labour's Rendition Scandal.
Sun 26th Mar 2006:
Dundee Liberal Democrats in force at Scottish Liberal Democrat Conference.
Sun 5th Mar 2006:
"SNP in turmoil," say Dundee Liberal Democrats.
Wed 1st Mar 2006:
Dundee Liberal Democrats condemn fly tipping problem.
Thu 23rd Feb 2006:
Dundee Liberal Democrats highlight Labour's shameful record on climate change.
Fri 17th Feb 2006:
Dundee Labour MP's support of compulsory ID cards criticised by Liberal Democrats.
Fri 10th Feb 2006:
Dundee Liberal Democrats congratulate Willie Rennie!
Tue 7th Feb 2006:
Dundee Liberal Democrats welcome new free nationwide bus travel launch.
Sat 4th Feb 2006:
Dundee LibDems highlight criticism of the government over tax credit fiasco.
Mon 30th Jan 2006:
Dundee Liberal Democrats support Scotland's Commonwealth Games Bid.
Tue 22nd Nov 2005:
Dundee Liberal Democrats welcome Kennedy's new pension reform policy annoucement.
Thu 4th Aug 2005:
Tax Credit Chaos - Dundee Liberal Democrats highlight the issue.
Thu 7th Jul 2005:
Dundee LibDems say - "National ID Cards: No Thank You!".
Fri 6th May 2005:
Dundee Liberal Democrats launch new website!
